John Cleal, (F.V. Management Services Ltd, Nelson, New Zealand) and colleagues have produced a draft final report for the Conservation Services Programme (CSP) Technical Working Group TWG) of New Zealand’s Department of Conservation for Project MIT2011-07 "Warp strike mitigation devices in use on trawlers > 28 m in length operating in New Zealand fisheries" (click here).
The scope of the CSP is the impact of commercial fishing on protected species in New Zealand fisheries waters. The TWG has been reviewing the report during the course of the month.
The report’s abstract follows:
“The use of devices that aim to reduce seabird strikes on trawl warps has been required on New Zealand trawlers > 28 m in overall length since April 2006. Seabirds may strike, or be struck by trawl warps while feeding opportunistically astern trawl vessels. These strikes can cause injury or death. We examined two of the three legally-specified seabird scaring devices - paired streamer lines and bird bafflers - with the aim of improving their design, construction, durability, and ultimately performance and efficacy at sea. For bafflers, we also sought to use existing data to compare the efficacy of 2- and 4-boom designs. At-sea trials of streamer line materials were conducted on a deepwater trawler 105 m in length. These trials produced clear recommendations on streamer line materials and construction. Of the four tested, the best performing streamer material was Kraton. The optimal configuration for streamers involved direct attachment (i.e., interweaving streamers into the backbone and not using clips or swivels) at 3 m intervals along the backbone of the streamer line. The best-performing terminal object of the five tested was a trawl float 360 mm diameter and 9.1 kg in weight. This could be replaced by a 6.5 kg trawl float of the same diameter on vessels with lower block height. Deploying a terminal object of 1.2 kg for every 1 m of vessel block height is recommended. Amongst the 30 – 60 m lengths tested, a backbone of 30 m almost always performed best. Deploying 5 m of backbone for every 1 m of vessel block height is recommended. These recommended design specifications have been captured in a fact sheet, and promulgated amongst the deepwater trawl fleet. For bafflers, a step analysis showed that processing waste discharge is consistently more important in determining the prevalence of trawl warp strikes than whether these devices comprised two or four booms. However, the data available were insufficient to support more in-depth modelling. Drawing on the design, construction and performance features of bafflers currently deployed in the fleet, an improved baffler design is proposed. Further work comparing the performance of bafflers of different designs quantitatively is also recommended.”
Black-browed Albatrosses gather behind a trawler. Photograph by Graham Parker
Click here to access the New Zealand National Plan of Action to Reduce the Incidental Catch of Seabirds in New Zealand Fisheries and accompanying fact sheet
Cleal, J., Pierre, J.P. & Clement, G. 2013. Warp strike mitigation devices in use on trawlers > 28 m in length operating in New Zealand fisheries Draft Final Report: At-sea trials and analysis Conservation Services Programme Project MIT2011/07. Nelson: Clement. 43 pp. + appendices.
With thanks to Barry Baker for information.
John Cooper, ACAP Information Officer, 26 February 2013